​ANONYMOUS, CONFIDENTIAL, TEXT OR VOICE
Why Do They Do It?
You want to know why he did it. He can’t tell you.
You may never know. He probably doesn’t know.
therapist for young people with harmful sexual behavior, to parents
Important Note
The impact or trauma for children who were harmed needs to be determined separately from the reason for their sibling's behavior.
One of the tragedies of harmful or abusive sibling sexual behavior is that the lifelong impact on children who were harmed remains, no matter the level of understanding, intention, or accountability of the child or young person who is responsible. The damage to the victim or survivor's body, spirit, and mind is a consequence of their sibling's behavior. The extent of the harm is not determined by the age, the motivation, or the culpability of the sibling who caused the harm.
​
The reasons or contributing factors for a child's abusive or harmful sexual behavior should never be used as a reason to minimize the level of trauma and the need for safety and services for the sibling who was harmed. This is true no matter their age or the amount of time that has elapsed since the harmful sexual behavior ended.
Similarly, the level of trauma the survivor has experienced should not be the sole factor determining the response to the sibling who caused the trauma. While it does need to be addressed as part of treatment and taking responsibility, it should not be the deciding factor governing what kind of treatment, consequences, or legal action are best.
Factors that Often Play a Part in Harmful or Abusive Sexual Behavior
None of these factors is a single underlying cause for a child or adolescent to engage in harmful sexual behavior. They should not be used as excuses, or to dodge responsibility, or to minimize the trauma and need for help for the sibling who was harmed, or to negate the need for treatment and help for the child who caused the harm. They are listed to give you, the site visitor, insight into possibilities as you reflect on the path that led to abusive or harmful sexual behavior in your life or your family.
Porn: This is a quickly-rising factor leading children to sexually harm others today. No matter how vigilant and careful parents are, no home is porn-proof in the internet age. It is increasingly common for children to be exposed to online porn, including content depicting violence and/or sexual contact between siblings, before the age of 10. When children and teens view porn, it blurs their boundaries and distorts their expectations for in-person sexuality. Most children who have viewed porn do not act out physically against other children. But children are naturally curious and inclined to imitate what they see adults doing. They cannot understand that what is portrayed as pleasurable on a screen would be painful, traumatic, and illegal in real life. Compulsive and addictive behavior related to porn use is becoming increasingly common in adolescents. See our page: Pornography & Harmful Sexual Behavior. Sources: Collective Shout: I was a child abuse detective. And even I couldn't protect my child from porn, Inquiry into Age Verification, Parliament of Australia, Office of Children's Commissioner Report (UK): Basically, porn is everywhere, Your Brain on Porn: Review of Literature, National Center on Sexual Exploitation Research Reports
​
Prior abuse of the child causing the harm: Some children who sexually harm others have been sexually traumatized in the past. Most child sexual abuse is unknown to adults. Many children may deny being sexually abused (especially boys and men), or do not even remember it. They may actually find it easier to admit they did something wrong than to admit that wrong was done to them. Research suggests that around half of children who display harmful sexual behavior were previously sexually abused. It is also important to note that most children who have been sexually abused do not go on to harm others.
Exposure to other kinds of abuse in the home: Even if a child has not been directly sexually abused, experiencing or witnessing physical or emotional abuse raises the risk of the child crossing boundaries and behaving in an abusive way toward siblings or others. Sometimes children who suffer from parental neglect will turn to siblings for physical or emotional comfort, and this comfort becomes sexualized over time.
​
Exploitation by an adult who coerces the children to perform sexual acts: Sometimes the adult who entices the children to behave sexually with each other acts in person, such as a family member. Increasingly, children are being coerced online to perform and/or record sexual activity. Children are further exploited when others view this material, either live or online. Recorded images are often used to threaten or blackmail the children as well, a horrific downward spiral. Sources: Internet Watch Foundation Report: Child Sexual Abuse Material of a 'Self-Generated' Nature. 20,000 Reports of Coerced 'Self-Generated' CSAM Show 7- to 10-year Olds, Anonymous Reporting Tool for CSAM (Child Sexual Abuse Material), Take It Down! Tool for images taken before age 18
​
Opportunity and Immaturity: Preteens' and teens' brains have not yet developed the full capacity to control their impulses. They cannot predict the consequences of their actions as well as a mature adult. Their sexual curiosity and desire may be greater than their self-control. Siblings may be the only other children they are around without adult supervision. Tragically, youth often act out sexually against a sibling simply because the sibling is easily accessible.
The peak age range for anyone to engage in behavior that sexually harms a child is 11-14 years old. At this age, they are still children, below the age of consent. The vast majority will never be charged with a sexual offense later in life. See our page: Youth Aren't Adults
Atypical Development or Neurodiversity: Children whose physical and sexual development outpaces their mental maturity and social skills seem to be at higher risk for harmful sexual behavior, as well as higher risk to be sexually exploited. Social isolation can also play a role. See our page: Unique Brains and Harmful Sexual Behavior.
​
Inadequate parental supervision: There’s no way around it: many parents have to work, have to care of other children in the family, have their own human stresses and limitations. Homes have limited space. No parent can or even should supervise all children 24/7. Children can gain a lot of benefit from unstructured time with each other. Yet it is frighteningly easy for parents to put a child in a situation that the child does not have the self-control to handle appropriately, such as babysitting a younger sibling or sleeping in close quarters.
Stress: Stress diminishes anyone’s ability to control their impulses. Children have a limited capacity for self-control to begin with. A child who is facing a stressful situation or living in a stressful environment may be more likely to act out sexually, to be unable to contain their actions.
Jealousy or Family Power Dynamics: Children who sense they are in a favored position within the family may take advantage of their status, knowing it protects them from parents believing what they have done or enforcing consequences. On the other hand, other children who are jealous of other siblings’ favor or status in the family may turn to sexual abuse as a form of retaliation.
Alcohol or Drug Use: These can reduce self-control, and are a risk factor for crossing sexual boundaries at any age.
​
Sources: Faure-Walker & Hunt 2022, Finkelhor et al 2009, Grant et al 2009, Joyal et al 2016, Latzman et al 2011, McKibben et Al 2017, Pratt et al 2012, Wortley & Smallbone 2006
Children or even teens who sexually violate their siblings rarely realize the extent of the harm they are causing. Their actions tend to be driven more by immaturity and impulsivity than by innate sexual deviance. Depending on their age, maturity, and life experience, they may not have a clear understanding of the boundaries they are crossing or the harm they are causing. Even if they intentionally did something wrong, young offenders often respond well to treatment and/or change their behavior when they mature. ​
This does not negate the reality that there are some young people who do remain a danger to their siblings and others in the future, and who need boundaries and consequences that fully recognize this.
The Pyramid of Responsibility
for harmful sexual behavior in children and young people
Any person, of any age, who initiates sexual activity with a child is responsible for their actions. But no one makes choices in a vacuum. The outside influences and events that contribute to these tragic actions are real. And in the case of children and teens, many of the factors that influence their behavior lie outside their control.
This pyramid is intended to show two things:
1. Children's and young people's individual behavior is influenced by the family they are raised in. And that family is influenced by the society and culture in which they live.
​
2. Some factors that contribute to harmful or abusive sexual behavior are within our control. These are listed within the colored pyramid. Others lie outside anyone's control. These are listed outside the pyramid, on each level.
​
While a child who initiates sexual activity with a sibling needs to take responsibility for their choices and behavior, families and societies also need to take action and ownership of the factors that lie under their control.​
graphic by Brandy Black, pyramid concept by Lobos-Sucarrat, ONG Paicabi, 2024
Hear more about the Pyramid of Responsibility from Paula Lobos-Sucarrat, in this video from #SiblingsToo Day 2024, with host Nancy Morris.
Additional Resources
-
Harmful Sexual Behavior: Solid Advice for Parents from a Juvenile Court Judge | Defend Young Minds
-
11 Factors That Increase the Risk of Child Sexual Abuse | Saprea This article is focused on risk factors for a child to be sexually abused, by siblings or anyone. It gives insight into ways that the child who was harmed may have been vulnerable. And there is significant overlap with the risk factors for causing sexual harm, whether that child was previously sexually abused or not.
-
What Happens Now: Facing Sexual Behavior Problems with Your Child | Online Booklet: National Children's Alliance
-
Do Children Sexually Abuse Other Children? | Online Booklet: Stop It Now!
-
Healthy Families | Familias Sanas Book for parents of children after harmful sexual behavior, Safer Society Press
-
Sibling Sexual Abuse: A Guide for Confronting America's Silent Epidemic | Book, Brad Watts
-
Adam Shares His Story | SiblingsToo Podcast host and SSA survivor Nancy Morris has a conversation with Adam, a young man who sexually harmed his sibling
-
In Their Own Words: What Might Have Stopped Me | Our Voices Blog by 5WAVES summarizes McKibben et al, 2017
-
Evidence on pornography's influence on harmful sexual behaviour among children | 2023 UK Children Commissioner's Report
-
Collective Shout article: I Was a Child Abuse Detective. And Even I Couldn't Save My Child From Porn.